Pie Guy's Pizzeria - Picton, Ontario

Ashish M.

Pie Guy’s Pizzeria at PEC is a wonderful spot run by elderly owners who provide truly great service. Their friendly and welcoming approach makes every order feel special. The food quality is excellent, with fresh ingredients and tasty options like their famous wings, meat pies, and pizzas that arrive hot and satisfying. Customers appreciate their reliability and the personal touch, especially for late-night delivery in Picton.

Leslie C.

Walked in and tried to order and was told I could not order because he had 8 orders in total. I have Cooke my entire life I have never heard of anything like that! 9:44 on a Friday night! Def can’t say the county’s choice for late night pizza when you can’t get one at a quarter to 10!
Try your luck I guess

Helen G.

Pizza was very pricey ( three medium for $80)and just okay. Some in our party found the pizza inedible. When we called we were told thin crust but it feels heavier . Folks in our party suggested it tasted uncooked. Maybe because there was a lot of cheese and sauce. The previous positive reviews were not experienced by our group. I have eaten a lot of pizza in NY, Italy, Montreal and Toronto. The pizza is not at that hype. Also, there is no formal receipt. The server indicated the price and gave me the credit card receipt (no break down of the pizza prices or the tax). This feels odd. We waited a bit longer for the pizza and there is no waiting area. You have to wait outside or in your car.

sacha S.

Great pizza! Crust with a little chew, the way I like it. Tasty sauce! Good amount of toppings. Can you believe they deliver til 2am? Can't wait to go back and try the jerk chicken. Check the menu, there's lots there besides pizza. Gave 5 for atmosphere cause the pizza was so good, but it's a takeout place, no seating. Order ahead.

Lisa W.

Food chicken wings once correct order came last night. They were so perfect.
Service was the delivery driver Lisa. She literally advocated for the correct order to be sent at close.
Cook.. despite disagreeing he heard wrong hot wings(actually should have been honey garlic)
He cooked them to perfection and I thank him.
Hate hot food, was corrected. And Lisa will.be why I return.. amazing and much appreciated

Nathan B.

The jerk chicken on the pizza we had was fantastic. It had a good amount of spice to it. There was more cheese on the pizza than I would have liked, but I know some people would really like it.

The chicken wings were also quite good, and the Caesar salad was nice and fresh.

Alex M.

We are Toronto-nians who own a vacation property near Picton in Prince Edward County. Being foodies from the city, we didn’t expect to find much locally in terms of gourmet pizza. Pie Guy’s was an awesome and unexpected surprise! Hands-down this is the BEST pizza and pasta joint in town. Awesome pizzas, homemade wings and Cesar salad to rival any steakhouse; all made with real ingredients and prepared on-par or better than the best joints in Toronto. Super friendly service can be expected very time!

PS don’t come to this place if your worried about your waste line but definitely come if you want awesome food!

Kathy G.

The pizza fresh ingredients could use little more spice flavors 😋. The price was expensive for the pizza slice and server said cause Prince Edward County that prices higher .
The crust reminds me of a flat bread type .