Oscar’s Pizzeria - Simcoe, Ontario

José D.

At first I just bought a pepperoni slice. The pizza crust was light, fluffy had air pockets. The sauce was very tasty but not overpowering the cheese was tasty and a pepperoni were spot on.

I came back and got a combo with a large pizza, a pasta and garlic bread.

The pizza came with five toppings they were amazingly fresh tasting the pepperoni had a bit of a bite to it which was really good. The sauce was exactly like it was in the pepperoni slice as well as the pizza crust for a light fluffy great.

We chose the spaghetti as our pasta. The meat sauce was really good, it had a roasted garlic flavor to it, the pasta was cooked perfectly and the cheese that they melted on top really set it apart.

The bread used for the garlic bread was thick cut thinking Italian loaf or something it definitely wasn't store-bought sliced bread or something

Lucille T.

Ordered large pick up special with 4 toppings online (first timer discount) and pizza was ready by the requested time. Price is really good at$16. Pizza tasted great with flavorful sauce, zingy pepperoni, generous amount of cheese, the crust was very light/airy which I'm not used to but we really enjoyed this 'za and would recommend it highly!

Reena

I decided to try this pizza place based on reviews and it did jot disappoint! I ordered a veggie pizza and parmesan bites - both tasted fresh and delicious. Oscar's is now on my list for a go-to pizza place.

RockyNinja

First order here. Been wanting to try it since some recommended it on FB. A bit of a wait for the pizza if you do walk in. That probably had to do with it being dinner time.

The person taking the order seemed a little stressed and that just put me in the same mood because I needed time to review the menu for the first time. I felt rushed.

In the end, I took the pizza home and didn't bother eating it. The whole interaction rubbed me the wrong way. Wife liked it so I guess that counts. Probably won't be back.

Rod C.

We ordered 10 pizzas for a party and they were great! We left it up to the pizza chef to mix up the toppings according to what most people ordered. There wasn't a single slice left over! That says it all...

Curtis E.

The staff is very friendly and they lived up to their promise of when it will be ready. This is our first time eating here and we are very pleased. It's my belief that a pepperoni pizza is the best way to judge a pizzeria and his did not disappoint. We also had the firehouse and cheeseburger pizzas, both are exceptional. We recently moved to simcoe and this is our new pizza place.
Thanks, Oscar!!

Steven W. (.

Just tried this for our first time. And let me say this… I’m not sure why I waited this long to try them out. They were closed during Covid. So we finally got the chance to try this pizza and I am not disappointed at all! It was very hot when we picked up also!!
They even leave a dough ball in the centre of the pizza instead of a pizza tray.
I find that to be a unique touch! We love it very much! And will make this our new go to pizza spot for sure!!

E

We were in town for the day and looked for pizza places nearby, and decided based on the reviews and especially the photos, that this place looked great. Unfortunately, those photos are misleading. This pizza was like a thin crust frozen pizza, and the sauce tasted like jarred spaghetti sauce. Very disappointing

Edit after owners response:
We were told it would be a 40 minute wait, we were there within 45-50 minutes. We were definitely not an hour late, but regardless, good pizza is still good the next day; an hour should not make or break it.