Piper Arms Whitby - Whitby, Ontario

Victoria Loney

Absolutely fantastic! We ordered lunch for the whole office for our staff and all the food was 15/10. Everything was fresh, warm and delicious. Would recommend to anyone who is in the area to try. Also, the menu is so versatile, any one would be able to find something they liked. As well, the potion sizes for the price was insane! A whole roast beef dinner with Yorkshire pudding for $20? How can you go wrong! The cooks in the back must really know what they're doing as it is hard to get an order as large as ours completely correct!

Sam de Zoysa

A great experience on Sunday having lunch with a friend. Sheridan was a lovely server, very friendly and helpful with answers to our million questions and requests.
Food was excellent. It was hard to choose what to order as there was so much choice. But finally I went with Yorkshire Pudding as British Fare is 25% off on Sunday. It did not disappoint! Large portions at reasonable prices and tasted great.
Will be back for sure and highly recommend.

Kay JV

I went for dinner on Sunday night with some family. It was my first time there though they go regularly, and I can see why! We started with salad, deep fried pickles and bruscetta. Can I say YUMMY?!! Especially the bruscetta - best I've ever had anywhere. I ordered the lamb shank, and though it was very tasty, it was quite tough. The waitress came over to see how everything was and I mentioned it. She offered to bring me something else, but I said no. Right after that another person came to the table and said "I heard the lamb was tough" (and he saw me struggling with the bone) "can we make you something else?". So I ordered the Salmon with Pad Thai. It was absolutely delishes! Hence the 5 star for food. One minor issue with a dish that was quickly resolved, plus the rest of the wonderful food, was really impressive. Our waitress (I think her name was Andrea) was an absolute delight. Very attentive and friendly. I'm only sad that I live nearly 3 hours away and can't come more often.

Grace Fam

Update:
Despite the owner reaching out on my review to apologize and asking for me to contact him to discuss the incident further, I have no desire to do so. I will refrain from returning and will not recommend this restaurant to anyone.

Original review:
My family and I visited this restaurant tonight and we were highly disappointed. I ordered the Butternut Squash Ravioli, which was supposed to feature crispy sage and fresh ingredients, but it was swimming in butter with soggy sage, excessively spicy pecans, and thin apple slices swimming in oily butter sauce. The red peppers in my dish were pickled and came from a jar, not fresh like the ones in my husband’s dish. The menu did not indicate that my entire dish would be spicy; only the pecans were labeled as such, yet the whole meal was overwhelmingly spicy.

My husband ordered the Louisiana Creole, by recommendation of the waitress. It arrived with cheese, despite no mention of it on the menu. When I questioned this, the server shrugged it off, saying it “comes like that.” It was unprofessional and misleading. Although my husband is not allergic to cheese, he’s been advised by his doctor to avoid it to avoid stomach upset.

In addition to that, there was also a pile of cheese on our Caesar salads. A good restaurant will ask you if you want cheese, not just dump it on top and expect you to be ok with it. Even though we said something to the waitress, she offered to get us something else but we declined. Come on, we all know what happens when you send food back.

The overall experience was poor. For a bill of about $110, including two kids’ meals and a dessert, this was far from a fresh, enjoyable meal. We’ve dined here before, but the quality has noticeably declined, and we won’t be returning. I would never recommend this place, especially if you want a meal with fresh ingredients that’s not drenched in a pool of butter.

Akshayah Tharma

We were in the area and decided to check this place out. Definitely glad we did, food was super good and the service was great. We tried the calamari, and battered mushrooms for appetizers and got the chicken curry & chicken carbonara for mains. Everything tasted great, but the mains really stood out. For pub food this really exceeded our expectations. Will definitely be back when in the area!

Gregory Grylls

Where do I start, from the moment I walked in Andrea was waiting at the door to seat me and make me feel welcome. Drink order was taken while sitting down and drinks at the table moments after. She advised our table of the specials instantly and recommended her favourites! ( amazing suggestions btw)

Food was delivered in a timely manner hot and fresh. Wings were a decent side and sauce choice out of this world.

For the quality and price range, I would highly recommend a visit, while here you should recommend Andrea to serve you, she is delightful and so wholesome.

April Cornish

HUGE menu! When you keep asking the waiter to give you a few more minutes to read up, make lists of preferences and discuss options with the table you know you are in for a treat!

I had the squash ravioli and it was delicious. Been other places where it was nice because they put nutmeg in theirs but they would only give you six wee pieces and you'd finish it wanting more. NOT THIS PLACE - they nailed it. Lots of lovely tasty perfectly squared up raviolis and lots of veggies swimming around in there too. Didn't finish my plate it was so much food. THAT is a first for raviolis for me! Well done.

The server was lovely. He was behind the bar and serving tables, was attentive, friendly and didn't have to write down our orders and we were a table of four. Love to see that.

The strawberry daiquiri was very good and if anyone is "following me on Google Reviews" let me add that you need to ask for two straws as I'm finding in my latest daiquiris that the thin straw gets blocked quickly and frequently and no one likes that.

Husband ordered steak yorkie and he couldn't finish it! The chicken wrap looked good and so did teriyaki stir fry. Definitely make this a regular for us!

Brooklyn C

Great food. Great service. Last visit was with a large group. Sat on the patio, they made sure we had water for the whole table. Food came out accordingly and hot. Servers were very friendly and efficient. not a fan of their gravy though.